Archives for: 2007, week 37

09/17/07

Permalink 01:09:35 pm, by Michael Email , 411 words, 241 views   English (US)
Categories: Tolkien Research

In celebration of Tolkien Week and Hobbit Day

Bilbo and Frodo's birthday has already passed. In our calendar it usually falls around September 13 or September 14. Most people, however, celebrate September 22 as The Birthday, completely forgetting that the Shire Calendar is not the same as ours.

Even The American Tolkien Society perpetuates the mixup and by now it's far too late to correct the error. We'll have to accept that by the time most Tolkien fans lift a glass of wine or soda to cheer Bilbo and Frodo, the magic day will have passed by more than a week.

Tolkien Week is defined to be that calendaric week (running from Sunday through Saturday) in which September 22 falls. That happens to be this week. The American Tolkien Society suggests that:

The most popular method of observing Tolkien Week is the library, bookstore or school display. Most libraries have bulletin boards or cases, and some have enclosed display tables and other facilities up to and including display windows of considerable size. Many librarians among our members and friends create displays; other members contact their libraries and assist in preparing displays.

Well, I'm all for an occasional visit to a library but I have Web sites devoted to -- well, to Tolkien, science fiction and fantasy, and even huckleberry products (which, personally, I feel Hobbits would love). In any event, I can say something about Tolkien Week and Hobbit Day on these Web sites, and by golly I am!

I posted an announcement on Xenite.Org but I've also shared the news at SF-Fandom's Tolkien Forum and the Endor discussion group (which used to be the Middle-earth mailing list).

It seems rather silly for me to have to find a school or library this late in the year that will help me celebrate Tolkien Week. Okay, maybe I should have planned ahead but I've been a little busy. The thing is, if you want to do something special to remember Tolkien and his Hobbits (this year marks the 70th anniversary of The Hobbit), then get together with some friends this Saturday and toast Tolkien. Do a reading.

But put something on your Web site, too. Or stop by the Tolkien Forum on SF-Fandom and say hello to your fellow Tolkien fans. You can still prepare a genuine hobbit feast (don't forget the huckleberries!) if you enjoy cooking. Or go find an English pub and have an ale, eat Shepherd's Pie, etc.

The point is, it's a special week for Tolkien fans. Remember the Shire!

Permalink 12:54:49 pm, by Michael Email , 922 words, 280 views   English (US)
Categories: Tolkien Research

Tolkienology - The Study of the Works of J.R.R. Tolkien and their influences

Tolkienology is an odd word that people really don't know what to do with. It's a bit like a preposition. Can you end a sentence with a preposition, like "with"? Sir Winston Churchill reportedly once said, when a woman advised him that it was improper to end a sentence with a preposition, "Madam, nonsense such as that up with which I shall not put."

He said so many apt things like that. Only this morning I saw another Churchill quote on an electronic billboard: "A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." Truth ever finds itself on the defense and in rebuttal. Rarely does truth leap out ahead of lies and fabircations.

And I use the word "fabrication" in the sense of an artificiality, a pseudoism such as an ill-informed attempt to explain something. If you search for "tolkienology" on the Web, for example, you won't find any generally accepted definitions. Someone suggested it has to do with the study of Middle-earth as if it's a real world.

I don't actually do that, but I can see how many people would think that is what I do. It's not that I strive to see Middle-earth as a real world. Rather, I strive to see the Middle-earth that J.R.R. Tolkien imagined. I'll never see his vision but I can pare away those things that provably are not his vision.

Other people do want to study Middle-earth as if it's a real world but I don't see any value in such study. The reason I wrote so many essays that explored Tolkien's histories and cultures was that I wanted to understand them. I wanted to understand the stories better. They are just stories, reflecting one man's natural opinion of how the stories should be told. But they are such fasinating stories.

Had anyone asked me what I think "Tolkienology" should mean I believe I would have always said, "The study of the works of J.R.R. Tolkien and their influences". That would be a suitably ambiguous Michael Martinez answer. In fact, I think the old Professor would appreciate the subtlety of such an answer.

For what could I possibly mean by "their influences"? Many people, I think, would leap to the wrong conclusion and suggest works like Old English poems, Norse sagas, Greek literature, Medieval literature, etc. Those are sources for Tolkien's works, no doubt about that. But though the sources may have influenced the works the sources are not themselves influences.

Rather, "their influences" must, I think, refer to the influences that Tolkien's works have had. They influence many things: literatary theory, cinematic theory, economic theory, social theory. They influence communities, disparate groups, individuals, and the educational world. Tolkien's works influence the media, other authors, and even industry.

J.R.R. Tolkien's influence is much broader, much deeper than can be measured in today's quantifications. We are stumbling toward a raw grasp of the momentity of Tolkien's reach across human experience. His ideas were not trivial for they have inspired legions of thinkers and doers to take action in more directions than I could ever hope to broadly generalize.

Liars, thieves, and slovenly fools have toiled in Tolkien's shadow. Great thinkers, giants of industry, and world leaders have acknowledged him in ways that our super-wealthy elite can only dream of. Old and young, near and far, people have discovered Tolkien's vision and looked up to glimpse Fairie from afar. A few, very few, have even seen the shadow of Mount Mindolluin overlooking the Bay of Eldamar.

Did I get my geography mixed up? Only a true Tolkienologist would know for sure. But Tolkienology is not simply about knowing; it is also about making, doing, and understanding.

It is the understanding that is the hardest, most challenging level of Tolkienology. Like a false prophet or false teacher, pseudo-understanding cries out with many voices: "Here is the way! It is over here!" But how can one fully understand the vision of a man who is no longer around to articulate that vision?

We have his words and no more than his words. His voice has fallen silent and we who wish to understand him must accept that he spoke in the idiom of a different generation, with the teachings and experiences of his own life's path, and there are relatively few left now who can remember him or know what he meant by what he said.

Tolkienology will soon begin to slumber and perhaps wrap itself in a coccoon, for the last of Tolkien's works has been published and his voice is now completely silent. There are no new words to resonate through our hearts. We can only hope that there will be a spring ahead to summon forth a beautiful creature from that coccoon of sleep.

For if we cannot understand Tolkien himself, or his vision, so fully, we can still be venturous enough to study the effect his works have on our lives. We can become true Tolkienologists by never looking back, only looking forward. For there is another hill or mountain awaiting our footsteps as we stroll down that merry, winding road he paved for us.

He is gone but will always be with us in our hearts and our thoughts. His works are a vial we hold up in the night. His influences are waves that ripple across the dividing seas, assuring us that we retain a connection to his vision.

Namarie! Maybe (even) thou shall find Vainor!

Michael Martinez

Michael Martinez shares thoughts and information about Tolkien Studies and research on the World Wide Web.

2007
<<  Current  >>
Jan Feb Mar Apr
May Jun Jul Aug
Sep Oct Nov Dec

Search

Categories

Linkblog

Misc

XML Feeds

What is RSS?

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 8

powered by
b2evolution